Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ian Sage's avatar

Go Ani, your posts have highlighted to me (again) of an aspect of resistance to many laws & ideas 'more generally' being that of 'misuse' or 'weaponising' of the law. I have often thought that the penalties for making a vexatious police complaint should be the same as that of that crime. This is a question of 'no substantial consequences' for 'deliberately' making a 'false' claim. I get the push back from the position of 'fear of making a claim', but if truth is not at the core, then all 'justice' fails. I also get the concern of the added 'stress' on the system however as you say, just because its 'hard' doesn't mean we should not consider it. Thoughts?

Claire Z's avatar

The FSU already knows I'm not a fan, but here's what gets to me about this concern voiced by Stephen Franks: "The law does not recognise that some people ought to be ashamed (“distressed”) by exposure of their own conduct.” This reflects a mindset which always focuses on the person expressing something and not on the person experiencing it, always on how something can be misused, not on how it might have benefits. That said, I agree that there could be a higher bar for those in public office, since they have a responsibility to listen to constituents and those affected by their behaviour. But they're human too and can still be subject to dangerous stalking.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?