Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jeff Grigor's avatar

This is the best article I have read on this issue.

Donna's avatar

Bravo, yet again, Ani! 👏

As a retired teacher and an old Nonna, I have watched this disaster unfolding close up, and yet from the distance and perspective of old age.

In 2005, I took time out from secondary school classroom teaching for overseas travel, then taught at university, so that when I again entered the classroom in 2013, I was staggered by the change in student concentration and behaviour!

The culprit the ubiquitous cellphone!

It was a constant nightmare trying to control its use. Eventually, the school tried to block students' electronic access to the internet. Ha! You can imagine how long it took the kids to circumvent that!

After a concerted staff revolt, phones were banned in class, and teaching was easier, but by then many students' ability to concentrate was severely compromised.

My own teenaged grand children were victims of the addiction. They'd come to stay, but spend all their time in their rooms on their phones. When we lured them out of their lairs for a chat, they still clutched their phones and surreptitiously played with them.

The kids may be connected electronically, but not in the real world.

Ani, I like your idea of backing up parents by physically banning smart phones for under 16s. Dumb phones would provide safety, but not scramble their brains!

Let's prosecute breaches by parents and phone retailers. Make it a crime, just like providing alcohol to minors.

We adults must protect children, but without losing our privacy in the process.

69 more comments...

Ready for more?